Setting a Safe Overbooking Level for Your Hotel

Set a safe overbooking level using your own no-show history. Learn how pick-up trends, guarantee rules, and walk costs determine your daily allowance.

11 min readTürkçe okuyun

About this postRevenue Management
Contents

What overbooking is and what the hotel actually promises

The promise is the confirmed reservation in the guest's hand; the room count is the supply in the hotel's hand. Overbooking separates the two on purpose, and the separation has a price: if one of the extra rooms cannot be honored, the hotel has to walk the guest to another hotel, cover the transfer and settle the bill. A hotel that has not priced that cost should not overbook.

For example, a 60-room hotel with 58 confirmed reservations for one night looks nearly full, but if its own history shows an average of two reservations not arriving on such a night, it can sell two more rooms. With those two sold it holds 60 reservations and 60 rooms; a third extra room puts the promise at risk.

How to derive a safe level from your own records

The safe level comes from your own hotel's count of reservations that did not arrive over the last few seasons, not from another hotel's table. The method is simple: for each night, put the confirmed reservation count, the arrivals that actually happened and the reservations that did not arrive side by side. The gap is your hotel's own no-show rate for that night.

Which nights you count separately

The no-show rate is not the same on every night, so do not squeeze the nights into a single average. Weekdays and weekends, holidays and peak season, nights booked months ahead through early booking offers and nights booked in the final week are counted separately. Split by channel as well: a reservation arriving under an agency contract does not behave the same as one booked on the hotel's own website.

How many seasons of data are enough

A single season, especially a good one, sets the level in the wrong place; look at the same night type across at least two, preferably three seasons. If the data is thin, keep the level small and record the actual arrivals at the end of every night; within a few months your own table forms. Starting the record today is building next season's level today.

What moves the overbooking level from day to day

The level is not a fixed number but a decision you revisit every day; the same hotel may overbook by two rooms one night and by none the next. What moves the decision is that day's pick-up: the net room nights that arrived since yesterday. If pick-up is fast and cancellations are falling, you lower the extra rooms; if pick-up has stalled and cancellations continue, you hold the level.

What to do with the level when pick-up stalls

When pick-up stalls, the reservations still coming in are the ones taken close to arrival, so pull the extra rooms down toward zero step by step in the days before arrival. Keeping extra rooms open in the final two days moves the risk of an unfulfilled reservation to the exact place where it is highest.

For example, on Monday you plan to overbook a weekend by 4 rooms; on Wednesday pick-up brought 3 rooms and two cancellations came in. If pick-up falls to zero by Friday morning, cut the extra rooms from 4 to 1, and by Saturday morning hold none.

How a length of stay restriction changes the level

On a night where you have set a minimum stay restriction, one-night reservations fall away and multi-night reservations rise, and that changes the no-show behavior for the night. Do not hold the overbooking level unchanged on restricted nights without counting their no-show rate separately. When and how to use the restriction itself is set out in the piece on length of stay restrictions.

  • Channel split: reservations from an agency contract cancel and no-show differently from the hotel's own channel; set the level on the hotel's total confirmed reservations, but note each channel's share.
  • Group blocks: if the block's pick-up lags, the rooms return to sale after the release date; those rooms are not part of the overbooking allowance because they are already in the hotel's hand.

Which reservations do not count toward the overbooking allowance

Not every reservation carries the same weight; some are unlikely to no-show and do not belong in the allowance. Before setting the level, separate the reservations that will almost certainly arrive and put the extra rooms only on top of the rest. A hotel that skips this step creates reservations it cannot honor.

  • Reservations with a credit card guarantee and an advance payment collected: if the guest does not arrive the room charge stays with the hotel, so the no-show chance is low and they do not count toward the allowance.
  • Long stays with an advance payment: the guest has already paid and the cost of changing plans is high.
  • Reservations under an agency contract with a cancellation penalty: if the contract's own clause makes a no-show expensive for the agency, count that reservation as firm.
  • Extensions by in-house guests and regular corporate-contract stays: those rooms are already occupied and do not enter the allowance.

If your guarantee and advance payment rules are weak, write those rules first rather than leaning on overbooking; when it is unclear which reservation can cancel free until when, how much advance payment is taken and what happens on a no-show, the overbooking level has nothing solid to stand on. Those rules are worked through step by step in the piece on a no-show policy built on advance payments and guarantees.

What to do on the night the rooms run out

When the rooms run out the decision is made in advance, not that night: who walks, who pays and how the bill closes must be written down. A front office that starts thinking at that moment picks the easiest guest, not the right one. Write the rule today and apply it at midnight.

Which guest is walked

The order is set in advance and built on the strength of the commitment, not on the guest's value to the hotel. The reservation that goes first is not the latest-booked, shortest-stay, lowest-rate one; it is the one with the weakest commitment. If you are caught between two guests on the same night, keep the one who has stayed with you before and booked through your direct channel.

For example, a 50-room hotel holds 51 confirmed reservations for a Saturday night, one extra room sold. If you must choose between a guest past the free cancellation window with a credit card guarantee and a guest from an agency contract, read the contract's own clause; if it carries no no-show penalty, move the agency reservation and call the agency the same day.

How the walk is paid for and closed

The transfer of the walked guest, the night at the other hotel and the charges at your hotel are gathered in a single guest bill, and when the bill closes the amount is marked as an overbooking cost. Total that amount through the season: set beside the revenue that came from overbooking, it tells you whether the safe level is actually safe.

For example, if a walked guest costs 900 lira in transfer, 3,200 lira for the night at the other hotel and 700 lira for a cancelled dinner at yours, that night's overbooking cost is 4,800 lira; if the extra room sold for 2,400 lira, the overbooking lost money that night.

Why the requests you turn away belong in the file

The overbooking level errs in both directions: sell too much and you walk a guest, sell too little and you leave a room empty. The second error only becomes visible if you record the requests you turned away. The front office should log every request on a full night with its date, room count, channel and rate.

The record builds next season's level; without knowing how many rooms you turned away this season, you cannot know how many extra rooms to sell next season. You will find how logging turned-away demand changes the estimate in the piece on recording the guests you turned away.

For example, if you turned away 30 rooms in a holiday week and 4 reservations did not arrive, your allowance was capped at 4 rooms and 26 rooms went unused; a level that could have sold half of those 26 is the right target for next year.

Does a shorter free cancellation window reduce the need to overbook

A shorter free cancellation window can reduce the empty rooms left by late cancellations, but only measurement tells you whether it truly lowers the need to overbook. While it changes cancellation behavior it can also reduce new reservations; do not decide without comparing both effects over the same period.

Which nights you measure

Compare the same night type, in the same season, under two different cancellation windows: the old window on one set of weekends, the new window on the next similar set. In both sets, record confirmed reservations, cancellations, no-shows and turned-away requests in the same format. How to set up the measurement is covered in the piece on what shortening the free cancellation window does to revenue.

For example, with the old 7-day free cancellation window a weekend brought 100 reservations, 9 cancelled and 4 no-showed; with a new 2-day window a similar weekend brought 92 reservations, 3 cancelled and 3 no-showed. The new window lost 8 reservations and saved 7 empty rooms; in this table, cutting the allowance from 4 to 3 is enough.

A checklist to put the safe level in writing

The safe level is not a number sitting in a table but a few rules applied the same way every day; writing them down takes midnight decisions out of the front office's hands. Work through the steps below in order and keep the result on one page.

  1. Put confirmed reservations, actual arrivals and no-shows for every night of last season into one table.
  2. Split the nights into weekdays, weekends, holidays and restricted nights, and calculate the no-show rate for each group.
  3. Remove the low no-show reservations (guaranteed, prepaid, penalized agency) from the base.
  4. Write one extra-room figure per night type and cut it every morning against pick-up until two days before arrival.
  5. Write in one paragraph which guest is walked when rooms run out, and who covers the transfer and closes the bill.
  6. Total the walk cost and the turned-away requests every week, and compare them with the revenue from overbooking at the end of the season.

When the steps are done you hold a decision rule rather than a number: how many extra rooms on which night, when to fall back to zero, and what happens when the rooms run out. Review the rule at the start of the season with the front office, reservations and revenue leads; through the season only the number should change, not the rule.

Share this post

Frequently Asked Questions

What percentage should a hotel overbook by

There is no ready-made percentage; the level comes from the hotel's own count of reservations that did not arrive. First put confirmed reservations, actual arrivals and no-shows for every night of last season into a table, then calculate the rate by night type. For example, if 19 of 640 confirmed reservations did not arrive, the rate is 3 percent, which at an 80-room hotel means about two rooms.

Which records does a hotel need before it overbooks

You need the confirmed reservation count, actual arrivals, cancellations, no-shows and the requests turned away on full nights, for every night. Keep them by channel and night type; reservations from an agency contract behave differently from the hotel's own channel. Starting the record today lets you set next season's level on your own data.

Does a hotel have to walk a guest when the rooms run out

You cannot keep a reservation you cannot honor; the task is to place the guest in another hotel, cover the transfer and settle the bill. Write this down in advance rather than thinking it through that night: rank which guest walks by the strength of the commitment, and read the agency contract's own clause. Collect the cost in a single guest bill each time so you can compare it with the overbooking gain at the end of the season.

When should the overbooking level drop to zero in season

Cut the level gradually to zero when pick-up stalls and arrival is a few days away. The extra rooms are no longer covered by expected no-shows, so holding them in the final two days increases the risk. For example, if pick-up falls to zero on Friday morning, cut the extra rooms from 4 to 1, and by Saturday morning hold none.

You've read it. Now, your hotel.

In a free review, we look together at how your hotel sells today.

Request your review

The review is free.